Join the Conversation

Join the Conversation.
I invite your comments, suggestions, and additional information about any topic mentioned. My hope is that this blog will be a dialogue rather than a monologue.

Thursday, June 4, 2015

Battle Hymn: Hero, Hollywood, and Controversy

Movie premieres are glitzy, spectacular events usually held in large cities. That's why the designation of Marietta, Ohio, as the location for the Battle Hymn world movie premiere in February 1957 was so improbable - and such a historic event for the community.

Battle Hymn tells the inspiring story of Marietta native Colonel Dean Hess's World War II and Korean War service. The latter included Col. Hess's role in rescuing and caring for hundreds of orphans in Korea. Col. Hess died this year at the age of 97.

I was in grade school at the time and recall much of the hoopla. It was brought to mind when tennis buddy Stev Pitchford sent me some of his photos of the parade. He was covering the events for WTAP in Parkersburg.

One unexpected twist occurred in my research: I learned that Dean Hess's version of the orphan "Kiddie Car" airlift - the event which brought Hess the greatest acclaim - was vigorously disputed by Dr. George F. Drake. In a 2004 publication, he claimed Hess exaggerated his role; see "Hess: Fraudulent Hero" by George F. Drake, Ph.D. at this link:
http://www.koreanchildren.org/docs/Hess=%20Hero-Thief.htm. More on Drake's claim below.

I had always wondered how Marietta was selected for the premiere. The Battle Hymn souvenir program gave me the answer. When Universal-International (U-I) announced the filming of Dean Hess's story, the Marietta community launched a campaign to convince U-I to premiere the film in Marietta. The "campaign" was not very organized, yet it "went viral" as a grass roots effort using 1950's communication modes.

Thousands of letters and telegrams poured into the office of David Lipton, U-I Vice President - from school kids, civic groups, community leaders, and ordinary citizens. Marietta College trustees proposed the college's Founders Day in 1957 for the premiere. Former Mariettans living in Southern California bombarded Mr. Lipton with calls promoting Marietta. "Never in all my years in show business have I seen such a civic push," Mr Lipton told reporters. "We were just overwhelmed." Marietta won the premiere.

Battle Hymn parade, photo courtesy of Stev Pitchford

There was a three day celebration in Marietta which began February 12, 1957, when the leading actors in the movie arrived in a motorcade from the Wood County Airport. The movie stars included the then wildly popular Rock Hudson as Dean Hess, along with other established actors of that time: Martha Hyer, Dan Duryea, Don DeFore, Anna Kashfi, and Jock Mahoney.

Rock Hudson was a big name leading actor with rock star popularity. He was well liked by all age groups and had earned a solid reputation as a dramatic actor. The Battle Hymn Souvenir Program said he...."was chosen for the role because the quiet sincerity of his manner which so closely resembled that of Col. Hess."

Rock Hudson on premier night, photo courtesy of Stev Pitchford

Martha Hyer played in numerous movies in the 1950's and 60's, and acted in guest roles into the 1970's. She was not in Marietta for the premiere. Don DeFore likewise was an established actor with many movies to his credit, along with TV sitcom roles in The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriett and Hazel.  Anna Kashfi had a brief acting career and was probably best known for being married briefly to Marlon Brando.

Movie poster from imagefriend.com

Local festivities included public appearances of Col. Hess and the actors, a parade, vintage aircraft fly-overs, reception given by Ohio Governor (and Marietta native) C. William O'Neill, awarding of an honorary degree to Rock Hudson on Marietta College's Founders Day, a queen contest, and the movie premier itself. The movie was shown at the Colony Theater (the former Hippodrome, now named Peoples Bank Theatre, which is currently being restored), Putnam Theater (now Mid-Ohio Valley Players Theater), and Ohio Theater which is now a store front on Second Street.

Recollections of premiere events in Marietta, some from Dan Benson's Memories of Marietta Facebook page, of those living in Marietta at the time:
  • Charlie Kremer recalls standing on Putnam Street with his mother - who screamed like crazy when Rock Hudson's car passed in the parade. His father was not pleased with her reaction.
  • Libby Devol Murphy recalled "My sister and her friends jumped on Rock's vehicle as it crossed the Williamstown bridge and rode it all the way to the Lafayette... (Dean Hess) was (my mother's) cousin."
  • Rhoda Triplett laughed as she remembered that one of her friends was infatuated with actor Dan Duryea. As his car went by in the parade the friend leaped on the man standing in front of her for a better view. Whether from excitement or waiting too long, the friend wet herself and the unlucky guy she was holding on to.
  • I remember flinching at the deafening noise of the P-51 fighter plane (the type plane that Hess piloted) that flew over the parade on Putnam Street. It was so impressive that I urgently scraped together enough money (probably $1.98) to buy a P-51 airplane model which became Exhibit #1 in my room.
  • Judy Palmer Turtletaub McCahon said "Rock Hudson starred in the movie...He shook hands with me at the side door of the theater - me a kid !!"
  • Some locals were recruited to accompany the celebrities to local watering holes. Several remembered seeing them at Murphy's Supper Club. Apparently the partying was intense; some actors were reportedly kicked out. One photo of Rock Hudson in the parade, in which he appeared sullen, prompted the comment: "He was probably hung over."
Dean Hess was a remarkable individual. A Life Magazine reporter said Dean had three passions: children, flying, and faith. He began flying while still at Marietta College. Later he became a flying preacher, flying from one town to another to preach. He flew P-47s in World War II. Later he returned to the U.S. Air Force and was asked to teach South Koreans to fly and start an air force. Resources for his project were limited, forcing him to scrounge food and supplies for his fledgling unit. Col. Hess utilized on-the-job training and flew live missions with his cadets, showing them how and where to fly, drop bombs, and attack targets. He flew a total of 250 missions in Korea.

Book cover image from koreawarorphans.org

In between missions, he made time to help Korean orphans and children displaced by the fighting. He is credited with (a claim disputed by some) arranging an airlift dubbed "Operation Kiddie Car" to move hundreds of orphans from the mainland to a nearby island as enemy troops approached Seoul in December of 1950. He and his men also helped to provide food, clothing, and funds to support them. After the war, he wrote a memoir titled "Battle Hymn" about his experiences. Proceeds from the book and movie were used to build a new orphanage.

Rock Hudson pictured with actual Korean orphans who were brought from Korea for the movie.

Dean Hess was directly involved as an adviser to the Battle Hymn movie production. He vetoed Robert Mitchem, originally chosen to portray Hess, because Mitchem had done prison time. Life Magazine reported that Hess flew in some movie scenes and recreated actual battle events himself. Whenever the P-51 plane bearing the number 18 (the number on the plane he flew in the war) appears in the movie, Hess is piloting the plane.

Hess's plane with By Faith I Fly insignia from forum.warthunder.com

Also on that plane, the inscription "By Faith I Fly" appears - in Korean symbols. His motto became the inspirational icon of Hess's heroic role in Korea. Hess's nephew Bill Hess of Marietta explained that the phrase became the motto of  the Republic of Korea (ROK) Air Force Academy. Thousands of ROK Air Force trainees over many decades have learned the motto and the story behind it.

George Drake disputed Hess's role in the orphan airlift nearly 50 years after it occurred. Drake gave Air Force Chaplain LTC Russell L. Blaisdell and Staff Sergeant Merle Y. Strang the credit for arranging the rescue. Drake says they stayed with the children in an abandoned school building waiting for a boat evacuation. When the boat failed to appear, Blaisdell improvised a new plan. He talked the Air Force into providing 16 C-54 transports to fly the 850 children and 80 staff to the island of Cheju-do. He also commandeered trucks need to transport the group to the airport.

Drake says these plans and the airlift were made without involvement of Dean Hess. He terms Hess's claim about organizing the airlift  as "fraudulent," and the many media stories about Hess's reportedly heroic role as outrageously inaccurate. Drake does credit Hess with donating book and movie proceeds to charity for the orphans. He also noted that Hess and his men worked tirelessly to support the children once they were relocated to Cheju-do. 

I have not seen other reports to refute or support Drake's claims. Bill Hess, Dean's nephew, says the claims made by Drake angered Dean and his family, but they chose not to respond. It doesn't matter, anyway. Dean Hess's war service and aid efforts to Korean orphans - before and after the war - are exemplary. And the Hollywood premiere extravaganza was a remarkable event for Marietta. 

Additional details about the Korean children and orphans helped during and after the war can be seen at the Korean War Childrens Memorial website: koreanchildren.org.

If readers have Battle Hymn memories of their own, please respond to this blogpost or let me know.

Sources:
Wikipedia - Battle Hymn movie and selected actors listed there
Battle Hymn Souvenir Program
Discussions with local persons
Memories of Marietta (OH) Facebook page
Dille, John, Life Magazine, "The Movie's Real Hero Flies by Faith," February 25, 1957 issue, Google Books
IMDb website, IMDb.com, Battle Hymn movie
Marietta Times, Dean Hess Obituary, March 6, 2015
LA Times, Dean Hess obituary, March 6, 2015 at latimes.com
Korean War Childrens Memorial website: koreanchildren.org


6 comments:

  1. A great article, very well documented and with never-seen-before pics! Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  2. George F. Drake, Ph.D.May 30, 2016 at 10:00 AM

    Hello:
    I have prepared a document for Korean media regarding plans to dedicate a memorial to Dean E. Hess for.... saving the lives of the children in the Kiddy Car Airlift. I will post it here in four sections as it is too long for your message box.

    George F. Drake, Ph.D.

    ReplyDelete
  3. George F. Drake, Ph.D.May 30, 2016 at 10:02 AM

    Of course I am distressed that the myth of Colonel Hess having rescued the children in the airlift of 20 December 1950 is still accepted as the truth in many quarters. Colonel Dean Hess has every right to be honored and have a memorial sculpture dedicated in his honor in the Republic of Korea for what he did do in creating the Korean Air Force. On the other hand it is a travesty of justice to honor him for what someone else did and deny them the posthumous justice of recognition of the dramatic rescue of almost a thousand children at the height of the Korean War.

    In my research on the relationship of the American servicemen and women and their relationship to the war child of Korea I uncovered the fraudulent claim that Dean Hess had played the leading role in the rescue of the children. Until the publication of Hess’ book “Battle Hymn” and the movie of the same title not a single published report made any mention of Hess rescuing the children. His role was merely that of having prepared the facility on Chejudo to house the children once they arrived by air from Kimpo, having been notified by Chaplain Blaisdell that they would arrive on the 20th of December. Hess was not in Seoul or Incheon at the time of the rescue. He was on Chejudo. He did not witness the rescue. He did not organize the rescue. He did not have any idea of what was happening with the children until they arrived in Chejudo.

    ReplyDelete
  4. George F. Drake, Ph.D.May 30, 2016 at 10:03 AM

    Only after the publication of the book and the making of the movie is Hess acclaimed as the hero of the Kiddy Car Airlift. Until then newspaper reports give Blaisdell credit for the rescue. A careful reading of the book will indicate that Hess gives no mention of what went on in Seoul and Incheon and how the trip from Incheon to Kimpo was accomplished. Of course not. He was not there. He was not part of the rescue. His comments regarding the arrival of the children on foot at Kimpo is pure fiction. He writes that the children were at the airport waiting for the planes to arrive when the opposite was the truth, namely the planes had to wait for over an hour until the first vehicle arrived with the children. Hess was writing fiction and by innuendo claiming credit for what others had done.

    After the book and movie came out Hess was acclaimed as the hero of the Kiddy Car Airlift and shamelessly never said “Stop. Yes, I helped but the real heroes are Chaplain Russell Blaisdell and S/Sgt. Michael Strang.” He never once made mention of the two persons who were ‘on the ground’ effecting the rescue. He took all credit for himself. Only in Bellingham in 2003 was Chaplain Blaisdell and S/Sgt. Strang awarded the highest award of the U.S. Air Force Chaplain’s Corp, the ‘Four Chaplain’s Award” for their rescue of the children in the Kiddy Car Airlift. After years of paperwork and effort I was able to get the Bronze Star awarded to S/Sgt. Michael Strang (posthumously) for his role in the rescue. Those awards were given only after extensive research by staff in the office of the Chief of Chaplains of the US Air Force. Those awards vindicated the claims that Blaisdell and Strang were the true heroes of the Kiddy Car Airlift.

    ReplyDelete
  5. George F. Drake, Ph.D.May 30, 2016 at 10:08 AM

    At an Air Force banquet in Florida (date?) Hess and Blaisdell were both recognized as Korean War Heroes, Hess for his work in founding the Korean Air Force and Blaisdell for the rescue of the children. Tom Brokaw had a clip of this banquet on his TV show shortly thereafter. His staff called me to reconfirm that Blaisdell was the true hero of the Kiddy Car Airlift. These TV programs are also available on the Koreanchildren.org web site.

    Since the publication of my essay “Col. Dean E. Hess: Fraudulent Hero” not a single critic of that essay has produced any shred of evidence that Hess was in Seoul or Incheon or even in Kimpo at the time of the rescue. The problem is that Hess began to believe the myth of him being the hero and never once did he acknowledge that Chaplain Blaisdell and S/Sgt Strang had anything to do with the rescue. He did not want anyone to interview them and possibly disprove the lie he was living. And the media, including the Stars&Stripes military newspaper reporters, quoted the film and the book as evidence of his rescue of the children.

    The net result of this lie, this fraud, was that Blaisdell was not recognized for his role in the rescue until his return to Korea 50 years later. Unfortunately Strang died without ever getting a single form of recognition or appreciation either from the Korean government or from the US Air Force for his absolutely essential role in the rescue of the children. THAT, to me, is a true travesty of justice.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am currently working on a video project about the premiere and would love to use a photo from your post. I'd be interested in getting contact information regarding obtaining permission for the first photo from Stev Pitchford. If you could send contact info to redturbojacketproductions@gmail.com, I would greatly appreciate it!

    ReplyDelete