I was surprised to learn that in the 1830s and 40s slaves from Henderson Hall Plantation just below Williamstown ran errands on their own in Marietta. That seemed unusual. The late Henry Burke reported that George W. Henderson owned as many as 30 slaves, “though many ran away in droves." We get a glimpse of slave treatment from experiences of those owned by George Henderson.
Slavery was permitted in Virginia, across the Ohio River from Ohio, a free state. Many Virginia slaves crossed the river and "boarded" the Underground Railroad (a secret network of helpers) to freedom in the north - or thought seriously about it. Those errands in Marietta put slaves in contact with Underground Railroad "agents," such as abolitionist David Putnam, Jr. It became a chess game: slave owners versus slaves and their Underground Railroad ("UGRR") helpers.
Some Henderson slaves were treated well. "Uncle Steven" Dingo and wife Julie delivered produce in Marietta and returned with payments to the Hendersons. They belonged to the First Congregational Church. Other slaves had similar privileges. Escaped slave Isaac Fairfax wrote (full text of letter below) to George Henderson, "I must acknowledge that you ever treated me kindly, … but longing for Liberty induced me to leave you..." Isaac then made an unusual request: He sought permission to return (if not punished) AS A SLAVE to the Henderson plantation. His request was granted; he returned in 1846. But even benevolent treatment of slaves didn’t alter the reality of being owned and controlled by their master.
Text of letter from Isaac Fairfax (Original document in Henderson Hall records):
Slaves were shrewd about manipulating owner relationships to improve their situation - or to escape. The Dingos siphoned off money due Hendersons to pay for their escape north. Isaac Fairfax promised that Henderson would "never have any cause to repent" of taking him back. Yet he left again within a year, taking with him other slaves and some money. For slave owners such as Henderson, constant vigilance was required - often with inspections, restrictions, and punishment.
Owners could buy and sell slaves, like real estate or a stock portfolio today. Documents indicate that an adult slave was worth $250-800 in the 1840s. Let's say Henderson's owned 30 slaves at an average value of $500. That's a total of $15,000 or about $500,000 in today's dollars. It’s hypothetical but illustrates the wealth influence of slave ownership.
Selling slaves could be a double-edged sword – a deterrent or incentive. A rebellious or recaptured slave could be "sold down the river" to cruel owners in the Deep South and separated from their families – a strong deterrent to running away. But slaves' knowledge of an imminent sale (possibly to worse conditions) could be a motivation to escape. That may be why 17 or more slaves left Henderson Plantation in 1846-48. George Henderson had slaves for sale in this period. A letter indicated that U.S. Senator Henry Johnson of Louisiana wanted to buy “about ten negroes” for sale by George Henderson.
Many slaves were assisted by UGGR “conductor” David Putnam Jr. Escaped slave Cesar Fairfax (brother of Isaac Fairfax?) wrote to Putnam from Salem, Ohio in 1848. He updated Putnam on other slaves living in the North, some from Henderson Hall. He said Isaac Fairfax and family were “doing well and contented” in Canada. His words reflected a tinge of nostalgia; He asked Putnam how things were “over at the Old Station,” presumably Henderson Hall. “Please send me word about mother (his own mother or Mrs. Henderson?) and news of “his old acquaintances.” A frustrated Henderson sued Putnam unsuccessfully to recover damages for the loss of his slaves.
George W. Henderson’s attitude toward slavery (not unique to him) illustrated a paradox typical of slave owners: they could be benevolent masters and “good Christian people” while strongly exercising their “right” to own human beings as property. Fortunately, many slaves gained their freedom through escapes and UGRR help or by the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863.
